Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe

Of all the culinary mashups in the world, few things have ever stopped me in my tracks quite like the first time I made this Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese. I remember it was a dreary, rain-soaked Saturday, the kind of day that demands a meal that feels like a warm hug. We were tired of the usual tomato soup and grilled cheese, and I had some leftover shredded chicken in the fridge. On a whim, I mixed it with some hot sauce and a bit of butter, layered it between two slices of thick sourdough with an almost obscene amount of cheese, and grilled it to golden-brown perfection. The moment my husband took his first bite, his eyes widened. The silence was broken by an emphatic, “Wow. Just… wow.” Since that day, this sandwich has become a legend in our house. It’s our go-to for game days, our celebratory meal after a long week, and the ultimate cure for a comfort food craving. It’s more than just a sandwich; it’s an experience. The spicy, tangy heat of the buffalo chicken, the creamy, gooey river of melted cheese, and the impossibly crispy, buttery crunch of the bread all come together in a symphony of flavor and texture that is simply unforgettable. This isn’t just a recipe; it’s a ticket to a new level of sandwich nirvana.

The Ultimate Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe

This recipe is designed to create the perfect balance of spicy filling, melted cheese, and crispy bread. We’re not just making a sandwich; we’re crafting an edible masterpiece. Follow these steps closely, and you’ll be rewarded with the best Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese you’ve ever had.

Ingredients

This recipe makes 4 generous sandwiches.

• For the Buffalo Chicken Filling:
  • 2 cups cooked and shredded chicken (rotisserie chicken works perfectly)
  • 1/2 cup Frank’s RedHot Original Cayenne Pepper Sauce (or your favorite buffalo-style wing sauce)
  • 2 tablespoons unsalted butter, melted
  • 1/4 teaspoon garlic powder
  • A pinch of black pepper
• For the Sandwich Assembly:
  • 8 thick slices of sourdough or a sturdy artisan white bread
  • 8 slices of sharp cheddar cheese
  • 8 slices of Monterey Jack cheese (or Provolone for a milder, creamier melt)
  • 4-6 tablespoons of salted butter, softened to room temperature (for grilling)
  • Optional: 4 tablespoons mayonnaise (for an extra crispy crust, see tips)

Step-by-Step Instructions to Sandwich Perfection

Crafting the perfect grilled cheese is an art form. We’ll break it down into three simple phases: creating the filling, assembling the sandwich, and grilling it to a flawless golden brown.

Phase 1: Preparing the Buffalo Chicken Filling

The heart of this sandwich is the zesty, flavorful chicken. Getting this part right is crucial for the overall taste experience.

1. Warm the Chicken: If your shredded chicken is cold from the refrigerator, gently warm it in the microwave for 30-45 seconds. Warm chicken will absorb the sauce more effectively and help the cheese melt from the inside out.
2. Combine the Sauce Ingredients: In a medium-sized mixing bowl, whisk together the Frank’s RedHot sauce, the 2 tablespoons of melted unsalted butter, the garlic powder, and the pinch of black pepper. The melted butter is a key secret; it adds richness and helps the sauce cling to every fiber of the chicken, creating a more luxurious texture than just using hot sauce alone.
3. Mix the Filling: Add the warm, shredded chicken to the bowl with the buffalo sauce mixture. Use a fork or a spatula to gently toss everything together until every piece of chicken is thoroughly coated in the vibrant orange sauce. Set the bowl aside while you prepare the bread and cheese.

Phase 2: Assembling Your Masterpiece

Proper assembly is key to preventing a soggy sandwich and ensuring an even distribution of cheese and filling. Think of it as building a delicious, edible structure.

1. Prepare the Bread: Lay out all 8 slices of your chosen bread on a clean work surface, like a large cutting board.
2. Butter the Outside: Spread the softened salted butter evenly from edge to edge on one side of each slice of bread. This will be the outside of your sandwich, responsible for that beautiful, crispy, golden-brown crust. For an even more epic crust, you can use mayonnaise instead of or in addition to butter (more on this in the tips section!).
3. Flip and Layer: Flip the bread slices over so the buttered sides are facing down. Now you’re working on the inside of the sandwich.
4. Create the Cheese Barrier: On 4 of the slices of bread, place one slice of sharp cheddar cheese. This bottom layer of cheese acts as a crucial barrier, protecting the bread from the moisture of the chicken filling and preventing it from becoming soggy.
5. Add the Filling: Spoon the buffalo chicken mixture evenly over the cheddar cheese on those 4 slices. Be generous, but avoid overstuffing. An overfilled sandwich is prone to leaking during the grilling process, creating a mess and an unevenly cooked final product. A good rule of thumb is about 1/2 cup of filling per sandwich.
6. Top with More Cheese: Place one slice of Monterey Jack cheese directly on top of the chicken filling. This top layer of cheese will melt down into the chicken, creating that incredible gooeyness we all crave.
7. Final Cheese Layer and Close: On the remaining 4 slices of bread, place the final slice of sharp cheddar. This ensures you have cheese on both sides of the filling. Carefully place these top slices onto the filled bottom slices, with the buttered side facing up. Gently press down on each sandwich to compact it slightly.

Phase 3: Grilling to Golden-Brown Perfection

This is the final, most satisfying step. The key here is patience and medium-low heat.

1. Preheat Your Pan: Place a large non-stick skillet, cast-iron pan, or griddle over medium-low heat. Do not use high heat! High heat will burn the bread before the cheese in the center has a chance to fully melt.
2. Grill the First Side: Carefully place 1 or 2 sandwiches in the preheated pan (don’t overcrowd it). Cook for 3-5 minutes on the first side. You’re looking for a deep golden-brown color and you should see the bottom layer of cheese beginning to melt around the edges. You can gently press down on the sandwich with a spatula to encourage even cooking.
3. Flip and Grill the Second Side: Using a wide spatula, carefully flip the sandwich. Grill for another 3-5 minutes on the second side, until it’s equally golden brown and crispy, and the cheese is completely melted, oozing out the sides.
4. Rest and Serve: Transfer the perfectly grilled sandwich to a cutting board and let it rest for 1-2 minutes. This allows the molten cheese to set up just slightly, preventing a cheese-lava slide when you cut into it. Repeat the grilling process with the remaining sandwiches.
5. Cut and Admire: Cut the sandwiches in half diagonally to reveal the beautiful cross-section of spicy chicken and melted cheese. Serve immediately.

Nutrition Facts

• Servings: 4 sandwiches
• Calories per serving: Approximately 750-850 kcal

Disclaimer: The nutritional information provided is an estimate and can vary significantly based on the specific brands of ingredients used, the thickness of the bread, and the exact amount of butter and cheese.

Preparation and Cook Time

• Preparation Time: 15 minutes
• Cook Time: 10 minutes per batch
• Total Time: 25 minutes

This quick turnaround makes it an ideal recipe for a satisfying weeknight dinner or a speedy weekend lunch.

How to Serve Your Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese

While this sandwich is a showstopper on its own, the right accompaniments can elevate it from a simple meal to a full-blown feast. Here are some serving suggestions, from classic pairings to more inspired sides.

Classic Dipping Sauces

A great grilled cheese deserves a great dip. These sauces complement the spicy and cheesy flavors perfectly.

• Blue Cheese Dressing: The quintessential pairing for anything buffalo-flavored. The cool, tangy, and funky flavor of blue cheese dressing cuts through the richness and spice of the sandwich beautifully.
• Ranch Dressing: A creamier, herb-infused alternative to blue cheese. It provides a cooling effect that balances the heat of the buffalo sauce.
• Extra Buffalo Sauce: For the true spice lovers, having a small bowl of extra buffalo sauce for dipping intensifies the signature flavor.

Traditional Sides

These are the tried-and-true companions that never fail.

• Celery and Carrot Sticks: Just like with buffalo wings, the crisp, cool crunch of raw celery and carrots provides a refreshing contrast to the hot, gooey sandwich.
• Classic Tomato Soup: The ultimate comfort food pairing. The acidity and sweetness of a good tomato soup cut through the richness of the grilled cheese, making for a soul-satisfying combination.
• Dill Pickles: A crunchy, briny dill pickle spear on the side is a perfect palate cleanser between bites.

Upgraded Sides and Snacks

When you want to turn your sandwich into a more substantial meal, consider these options.

• Sweet Potato Fries: The slight sweetness of the fries is a wonderful counterpoint to the savory spice of the sandwich.
• Onion Rings: The crispy, savory crunch of a good onion ring is a match made in heaven.
• A Simple Green Salad: A light salad with a vinaigrette dressing can add a fresh, acidic note that prevents the meal from feeling too heavy.
• Macaroni and Cheese: For the ultimate indulgence, serve a scoop of creamy mac and cheese on the side. It’s a cheese-on-cheese dream.

5 Additional Tips for Sandwich Supremacy

Ready to take your grilled cheese game to the pro level? These five tips will guarantee a perfect result every single time.

1. The “Low and Slow” Grilling Method is Non-Negotiable.
   It is incredibly tempting to crank up the heat to speed up the process, but this is the number one mistake in grilled cheese making. High heat will scorch the exterior of your bread long before the heat has penetrated to the center to melt the cheese. For that perfect, even, golden-brown crust and a fully molten, gooey interior, you must use medium-low heat and give the sandwich time to cook through gently. Patience is your most valuable ingredient here.
2. Unlock the “Mayo Secret” for an Unbeatable Crust.
   This might sound strange, but spreading a thin layer of mayonnaise on the outside of the bread instead of butter yields a superior crust. Why? Mayonnaise has a higher smoke point than butter, meaning it’s less likely to burn. The oil and egg in mayo also promote a more even, beautifully golden-brown, and incredibly crispy finish. You can use mayo exclusively, or a 50/50 mix of soft butter and mayo for the best of both worlds—the flavor of butter and the crispiness of mayo.
3. Build a “Cheese Barrier” to Banish Soggy Bread.
   The biggest enemy of a grilled cheese with a moist filling is a soggy bottom. To combat this, always place a slice of cheese directly onto the bottom piece of bread before adding any filling. This slice of cheese melts and forms a protective, delicious barrier that shields the bread from the moisture of the buffalo chicken, ensuring your bread stays toasty and crisp.
4. Practice Restraint: Don’t Overstuff the Sandwich.
   While it’s tempting to load your sandwich with as much of the delicious buffalo chicken filling as possible, more is not always better. Overstuffing leads to a messy grilling experience where the filling oozes out, burns on the pan, and prevents the sandwich from sealing properly. The filling also creates steam, and too much of it can make the interior bread soggy. Stick to a well-portioned layer of filling for a cleaner, more evenly cooked sandwich.
5. Let It Rest for a Moment Before Slicing.
   Just like a good steak, a grilled cheese benefits from a brief rest. Once you pull it from the pan, let it sit on the cutting board for 60 to 90 seconds. This allows the molten cheese to set slightly. If you cut into it immediately, the super-hot cheese will run out everywhere. A short rest ensures that when you slice it, you get that glorious, picturesque cheese pull without losing all the gooey goodness onto the board.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Here are answers to some of the most common questions about making the perfect Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese.

1. Can I use a different type of chicken?
Absolutely! While shredded rotisserie chicken is the fastest and easiest option, you can use any cooked chicken you have on hand. Leftover baked or grilled chicken breasts, shredded, work great. You can even cook chicken specifically for this recipe by poaching or baking two chicken breasts until cooked through, then shredding them with two forks. Canned chicken can also work in a pinch, but be sure to drain it very well first.

2. What are the best types of cheese for a perfect cheese pull?
For the ultimate “cheese pull,” you want to use cheeses that melt smoothly and have good elasticity. Monterey Jack is the champion of the cheese pull. Provolone and low-moisture mozzarella are also excellent choices. However, for the best flavor, it’s ideal to combine a “pulling” cheese with a “flavor” cheese. That’s why this recipe uses a combination of super-melty Monterey Jack for texture and sharp cheddar for that bold, tangy cheese flavor. A mix of Gruyère and Muenster is another fantastic, gourmet combination.

3. My bread always gets soggy. What am I doing wrong?
Soggy bread is a common problem with a few potential causes. First, make sure you’re using a sturdy, thick-cut bread like sourdough or a dense artisan loaf; thin sandwich bread will collapse. Second, implement the “cheese barrier” tip mentioned above—always have a layer of cheese between the bread and the filling. Third, don’t overstuff the sandwich. Finally, ensure your pan is properly preheated. Placing the sandwich in a cold pan allows it to sit and absorb moisture as the pan slowly heats up.

4. How can I adjust the spiciness of the sandwich?
You have complete control over the heat level. To make it milder, you can reduce the amount of hot sauce and increase the amount of melted butter in your filling mixture. Using a designated “mild” buffalo wing sauce instead of a straight cayenne pepper sauce will also significantly lower the heat. To make it spicier, you can add a few dashes of a hotter hot sauce (like habanero) to your buffalo sauce mix or even layer some pickled jalapeños inside the sandwich along with the chicken.

5. Can I make these sandwiches ahead of time?
While a grilled cheese is always best served fresh off the griddle, you can do some prep ahead of time to make assembly faster. You can prepare the buffalo chicken filling up to 3 days in advance and store it in an airtight container in the refrigerator. When you’re ready to eat, you can assemble and grill the sandwiches in just a few minutes. It’s not recommended to fully assemble and refrigerate the uncooked sandwiches, as the bread will become soggy over time.

Print